Think, oak island coconut fiber dating all became clear
Posted in Dating
The coconut fiber most recently highlighted on S07 E15 Surely Templar of Curse of Oak Island has long been discussed as a surprising find that requires some rethinking of local history. Why would coconut fiber end up in an archaeological context on an island in Nova Scotia, far from any area where it naturally occurs? Could it be that it is related to the burying of a treasure on the island, and to the building of the box drains that feed the flood tunnels that protect the money pit? In order to determine how interesting or significant the find of coconut fiber on Oak Island might be, we first have to see whether it is surprising in the first place. So just how rare is coconut in archaeological sites of comparable age in northeastern North America?
Scientists Solve Mystery Of Oak Island
By the mid th century, coconut was widely available in North America as far away as Toronto, and apparently not considered a luxury good. Archaeologists have reported coconut fiber dating from the 17 th and 18 th century, and coconut husk dating from the 18 th century in a site in Albany, New York Huey Albany is not exactly ocean front property.
It is a good km up the Hudson river from the ocean. In an archaeological report on a complex in Upper West Side Manhattan that mostly covers the period from the s to early 20 th century, and co-authored by Eva Hulse, with whom I worked for several years, a whole section is dedicated to the analysis of the coconut finds.
The report goes on to note that there were shipments of coconut into New York Harbour in alone, and about 8 million coconuts in total. The presence of coconut on Oak Island is therefore not surprising. That still leaves us, though, with the very interesting question of what it was used for in that place and at that time, especially the fiber. Even if we limit ourselves to what is shown on Curse of Oak Island, we know that there is plenty of farming and light industry on the island starting in the mid th century, not to mention the massive searcher activity that picks up in the midth century, that culminates in the mid th.
Coconut fiber has a number of commercial applications, that range from ship-building and repair, which likely happened on the island, to insulation, and rope production. Rope production from coconut fiber was important in the 19 th century, and some of it was even made in the UK.
Is it possible, then, that the coconut fiber found on Oak Island is from rope used in farming, light industry, and searcher activity from the 18 th to the 20 th century? Why yes, it certainly is possible.
Is it possible that Templar Knights who buried a fantastic treasure on Oak Island in the 14th Century left it there? That is also possible. Given the information available at the moment, I am closer to the Public Archaeology Laboratory Palinc n. You are commenting using your WordPress. You are commenting using your Google account.
The closest place coconuts were found in the 18th century was Bermuda, about miles due south of Oak Island. You might think this supports the pirate theory, since pirates certainly frequented Bermuda and the Caribbean. Some accounts of Oak Island have said that coconut fibers were found in large quantities buried beneath the beach, though this has never been evidenced.
A analysis by the National Research Council of Canada did identify three of four samples submitted as being coconut fiber. Radiocarbon dating found that the coconut came from approximately the year - three centuries before the first European explorers visited the region, and two centuries after the only known Viking settlement more than miles away.
How would year old coconuts get buried 50 feet underground when there was nobody around to do it, in a booby-trapped shaft that nobody had the technology to dig? It's really those flood tunnels that put the Money Pit over the top of anything you could expect pirates or anyone else to be responsible for, especially during a century when no Europeans were within thousands of miles. Divers would have needed weeks or months to cut subterranean tunnels from the bay nearby to the foot level of the Money Pit.
Or would they? The geology of Oak Island and its surrounding area gives us some more clues.
The region is primarily limestone and anhydrite, the conditions in which natural caves are usually formed. Ina farmer was plowing Oak Island just yards away from the Money Pit when suddenly her oxen actually broke through the groun into a 12 foot deep sinkhole above a small natural limestone cavern.
Oak island coconut fiber dating
Excitement raged that a second Money Pit had been found, but experts concluded that it was merely a natural sinkhole. Over the centuries sinkholes occasionally open up, trees fall in, and storms fill them with debris like logs or coconuts traveling the ocean currents.
These events, coupled with the underground cavern at the bottom of the Money Pit discovered in and the discoveries of numerous additional sinkholes in the surrounding area, tell us that Oak Island is naturally honeycombed with subterranean limestone caverns and tunnels.
The geological fact is that no Corps of Royal Engineers is needed to explain how a tunnel open to the sea would flood a 90 foot deep shaft on Oak Island, booby trap style.
Obviously the story has plenty of elements not thoroughly explained by the theory that the Money Pit was simply a natural sinkhole consistent with others in the area.
One such element is the stone tablet. There's a link to a drawing of it made by investigator Joe Nickell in the online transcript of this episode.
No photographs exist of the stone, nor any documentation of where it might ever have physically been. The transcribed markings are in a simple substitution cipher using symbols borrowed from common Freemasonry, and they do indeed decode as "Forty feet below, two million pounds lie buried", in plain English. The stone tablet made its appearance in the Onslow Company's records, coincidentally, about the same time they were running out of money and their pit flooded.
Most researchers have concluded that the stone tablet was probably a hoax by the Onslow Company to attract additional investment to continue their operation.
The same can be said of the other two significant artifacts, the links of gold chain and the parchment.
The coconut fiber found on oak island was in large enough quantities to not be just some lost rope(s). This article just says that coconuts were around at the time and coconut fiber had other commercial uses, but for an article about Oak Island, it has no context. Feb 10, Question on pre-columbian coconut fibre One of the scientifically supported facts of the Oak Island mystery is that a large amount of coconut fibres has been found at Smith's Cove. Tests have consistently shown that the fibres predate Christoph Columbus by decades or even a couple of centuries. Jul 13, Oak Island, coconut fibre and carbon dating. Oak Island Treasure is pleased to announce the addition of some new documents to its growing archive. The first is a new section on coconut fibre. Large quantities of coconut fibre have been found beneath the beach at Smith's Cove. Records suggest that this is over a foot deep in some places.
Accompanying his map, Joe Nickell said "The artifacts are not properly documented archaeologically, and most would appear to derive from historical activity on the island or from subsequent excavation or hoaxing by workmen. And as with so many other subjects, the older the account you read, the less specific and impressive the details.
The contemporary newspaper accounts of Daniel McGinnis and his two friends make no mention of a tackle block or of regularly spaced log platforms, only that logs were found in the pit, and that the tree branch showed evidence of a block and tackle having been used. Armed with proper skepticism and the willingness to look deeper than the modern sensationalized retellings, the Money Pit's intrigue and enchantment begin to fade.
I was probably no more than eight or nine when I first read about young Daniel McGinnis and his treasure tree, and at that very moment, Oak Island became a permanent part of me, as it has so many others. Oak Island's history is a patchwork of individual romances and adventures, a tapestry made from the reveries of skeptics and believers alike.
Whether building causeways and sinking caissons, analyzing old newspapers, swinging a pick in the glare of a lantern, or even listening to a podcast about the mystery, all of us share the same ambition.
Nov 25, The Oak Island Money Pit more oak, "broken bits of A analysis by the National Research Council of Canada did identify three of four samples submitted as being coconut fiber. Radiocarbon dating found that the coconut came from approximately the year - three centuries before the first European explorers visited the region, and. Mar 10, Archaeologists have reported coconut fiber dating from the 17 th and 18 th century, and coconut husk dating from the 18 th century in a site in Albany, New York (Huey ). Albany is not exactly ocean front property. It is a good km up the Hudson river from the ocean. It also isn't any more tropical than Oak Island. Nov 16, Carbon Dates for various Oak Island Artifacts. 11/16/ 4 Comments By Doug Crowell and Kel Hancock Radiocarbon (C) dating is one of the most reliable of all the radiometric dating methods. It has been utilized to scientifically test organic Oak Island artifacts many times since The coconut fibres' carbon dating is particularly.
No matter if we seek treasure or truth, we all long for the chance to turn just a few thrusts of the shovel, and we care not what we find. Please contact us with any corrections or feedback. Cite this article: Dunning, B. Skeptoid Media, 25 Nov Driscoll, C.
Welcome to the Oak Island Treasure blog!
Joltes, R. Critical Enquiry, 19 Apr.
Nickell, J. O'Connor, D.
Oak Island archaeology ate : Just how surprising is the coconut fiber?
Guilford: The Lyons Press, Teale, E. All Rights Reserved. Rights and reuse information.
The Skeptoid weekly science podcast is a free public service from Skeptoid Media, a c 3 educational noshawchapman.comofit. This show is made possible by financial support from listeners like you. If you like this programming, please become a member.
Many thanks for an explanation, now I will not commit such error.07.01.2020|Reply